sudokUI › Sudoku difficulty rating
Sudoku difficulty rating
sudokUI rates a puzzle by solving it the way a person would. At every step it takes the easiest technique that makes progress and adds that technique’s score. The total is the HoDoKu rating.
Rate your own sudoku
The puzzle opens in sudokUI with its HoDoKu rating and level in the top bar. Nothing is uploaded: the rating is computed on your own device. No string at hand? Open sudokUI, choose New, then Custom, and type the puzzle onto the board. See also how this compares with HoDoKu.
Easiest technique first
Techniques are tried in a fixed order, from singles up to forcing nets, and the first one that works is applied. The rating therefore measures a path built from the easiest steps available, not the cleverest one.
Scores compatible with HoDoKu
Scores and search order are HoDoKu’s defaults for every technique the two share; HoDoKu is the reference sudoku analyser. A Naked Single costs 4, an X-Wing 140, a Forcing Net 700. sudokUI’s solver also knows techniques HoDoKu does not, such as WXYZ-Wing, Chute Remote Pair and 3D Medusa, scored next to their closest relatives; it uses Death Blossom, which HoDoKu leaves off by default, and lacks HoDoKu’s Finned Franken fish. So the HoDoKu rating follows HoDoKu’s scale and rules, but on many puzzles it is not the number HoDoKu itself gives, and sometimes not the level.
HoDoKu’s five levels
The level is set the way HoDoKu sets it. It starts at the level of the hardest technique on the solve path, then rises one level at a time while the total is above the level’s limit: 800 for Easy, 1000 for Medium, 1600 for Hard and 1800 for Unfair. Extreme has no limit. A solve path with an X-Wing makes a puzzle at least Hard, and a total over 1800 makes it Extreme.
Beginner and Nightmare
New game also offers two narrower picks: Beginner, the Easy puzzles scoring 400 or less, and Nightmare, the Extreme puzzles scoring over 3000. They choose which puzzles you get; the level a puzzle shows is still one of the five.
Rate any puzzle
Import an 81-character puzzle or type one in by hand. sudokUI first verifies that it has exactly one solution, then rates it before you play.
The five levels and two picks
| Level | Total score | Typical techniques |
|---|---|---|
| Easy | up to 800 | singles only |
| Beginner | Easy, up to 400 | full houses and easy singles |
| Medium | up to 1000 | locked candidates and subsets |
| Hard | up to 1600 | fish, wings, kites and unique rectangles |
| Unfair | up to 1800 | chains, ALS and finned fish |
| Extreme | no limit | long chains, colouring and nets |
| Nightmare | Extreme, above 3000 | forcing nets and Exocets |
How fast is fast?
Rough benchmarks from the typical times online solvers report, spread the way solve times spread: most near the middle, a long tail behind. The world class mark is set by championship solvers. Writing your own marks takes longer than automatic candidates, and paper longer still, so each way of solving has its own table. Beginner and Nightmare puzzles are timed on rows of their own, so the Easy and Extreme rows are for the rest of those levels. A puzzle at the top of its level takes longer than one at the bottom.
| Level | Slow | Typical | Fast | Expert | World class |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| With automatic candidates | |||||
| Beginner | 6:44 | 4:00 | 2:22 | 0:57 | 0:35 |
| Easy | 11:48 | 7:00 | 4:09 | 1:39 | 1:02 |
| Medium | 20:13 | 12:00 | 7:07 | 2:50 | 1:46 |
| Hard | 38:45 | 23:00 | 13:39 | 5:26 | 3:23 |
| Unfair | 1h 16m | 45:00 | 26:42 | 10:38 | 6:37 |
| Extreme | 2h 32m | 1h 30m | 53:25 | 21:16 | 13:15 |
| Nightmare | 5h 3m | 3h | 1h 47m | 42:33 | 26:30 |
| With your own marks | |||||
| Beginner | 8:46 | 5:12 | 3:05 | 1:14 | 0:46 |
| Easy | 15:20 | 9:06 | 5:24 | 2:09 | 1:20 |
| Medium | 26:17 | 15:36 | 9:15 | 3:41 | 2:18 |
| Hard | 50:23 | 29:54 | 17:45 | 7:04 | 4:24 |
| Unfair | 1h 39m | 58:30 | 34:43 | 13:50 | 8:37 |
| Extreme | 3h 17m | 1h 57m | 1h 9m | 27:39 | 17:13 |
| Nightmare | 6h 34m | 3h 54m | 2h 19m | 55:19 | 34:27 |
| On paper | |||||
| Beginner | 10:47 | 6:24 | 3:48 | 1:31 | 0:57 |
| Easy | 18:52 | 11:12 | 6:39 | 2:39 | 1:39 |
| Medium | 32:21 | 19:12 | 11:24 | 4:32 | 2:50 |
| Hard | 1h 2m | 36:48 | 21:50 | 8:42 | 5:25 |
| Unfair | 2h 1m | 1h 12m | 42:44 | 17:01 | 10:36 |
| Extreme | 4h 3m | 2h 24m | 1h 25m | 34:02 | 21:12 |
| Nightmare | 8h 5m | 4h 48m | 2h 51m | 1h 8m | 42:24 |
Slow is where the slowest fifth begins. Typical is the median solver. Fast is faster than four solvers in five, Expert faster than 99 in 100, World class faster than 999 in 1,000. The app says where each of your solves lands.
Score of every technique
The cost added to a puzzle's HoDoKu rating each time the solver needs the technique, and how many of the puzzles sudokUI generates need it at least once (measured on 5,533,732 puzzles).
| Technique | Class | Score | Needed in |
|---|---|---|---|
| Singles | |||
| Full House | Easy | 4 | every puzzle |
| Naked Single | Easy | 4 | every puzzle |
| Hidden Single | Easy | 14 | 94% of puzzles |
| Intersections | |||
| Locked Pair | Medium | 40 | 1 in 12 puzzles |
| Locked Triple | Medium | 60 | 1 in 57 puzzles |
| Locked Candidates (Pointing) | Medium | 50 | 34% of puzzles |
| Locked Candidates (Claiming) | Medium | 50 | 17% of puzzles |
| Subsets | |||
| Naked Pair | Medium | 60 | 14% of puzzles |
| Naked Triple | Medium | 80 | 1 in 10 puzzles |
| Hidden Pair | Medium | 70 | 1 in 24 puzzles |
| Hidden Triple | Medium | 100 | 1 in 110 puzzles |
| Naked Quadruple | Hard | 120 | 1 in 840 puzzles |
| Hidden Quadruple | Hard | 150 | 1 in 12,000 puzzles |
| Basic Fish | |||
| X-Wing | Hard | 140 | 1 in 19 puzzles |
| Swordfish | Hard | 150 | 1 in 81 puzzles |
| Jellyfish | Hard | 160 | 1 in 1,500 puzzles |
| Squirmbag | Unfair | 470 | |
| Whale | Unfair | 470 | |
| Leviathan | Unfair | 470 | |
| Finned Fish | |||
| Finned X-Wing | Hard | 130 | 1 in 55 puzzles |
| Sashimi X-Wing | Hard | 150 | 1 in 260 puzzles |
| Finned Swordfish | Unfair | 200 | 1 in 68 puzzles |
| Sashimi Swordfish | Unfair | 240 | 1 in 330 puzzles |
| Finned Jellyfish | Unfair | 250 | 1 in 860 puzzles |
| Sashimi Jellyfish | Unfair | 260 | 1 in 7,200 puzzles |
| Complex Fish | |||
| Franken X-Wing | Unfair | 300 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| Franken Swordfish | Unfair | 350 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| Single Digit Patterns | |||
| Skyscraper | Hard | 130 | 1 in 11 puzzles |
| 2-String Kite | Hard | 150 | 1 in 13 puzzles |
| Turbot Fish | Hard | 120 | 1 in 60 puzzles |
| Empty Rectangle | Hard | 120 | 1 in 32 puzzles |
| Colouring | |||
| Simple Colors | Hard | 150 | 1 in 520 puzzles |
| Multi Colors | Hard | 200 | 1 in 890 puzzles |
| 3D Medusa | Unfair | 250 | 1 in 16 puzzles |
| Wings | |||
| W-Wing | Hard | 150 | 1 in 16 puzzles |
| XY-Wing | Hard | 160 | 1 in 16 puzzles |
| XYZ-Wing | Hard | 180 | 1 in 33 puzzles |
| WXYZ-Wing | Hard | 200 | 1 in 12 puzzles |
| Almost Locked Sets | |||
| ALS-XZ | Unfair | 300 | 1 in 37 puzzles |
| ALS-XY-Wing | Unfair | 320 | 1 in 50 puzzles |
| ALS-XY-Chain | Unfair | 340 | 1 in 98 puzzles |
| Death Blossom | Unfair | 360 | 1 in 2,400 puzzles |
| Chains and Loops | |||
| Remote Pair | Hard | 110 | 1 in 46 puzzles |
| Chute Remote Pair | Hard | 110 | 1 in 12 puzzles |
| X-Chain | Unfair | 260 | 1 in 260 puzzles |
| X-Cycles (loops) | Unfair | 280 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| Grouped X-Cycles | Unfair | 300 | 1 in 430 puzzles |
| XY-Chain | Unfair | 260 | 1 in 30 puzzles |
| Twinned XY-Chains | Unfair | 300 | |
| Nice Loop | Unfair | 280 | 1 in 25 puzzles |
| Grouped Nice Loop | Unfair | 300 | 1 in 160 puzzles |
| Alternating Inference Chain | Unfair | 320 | 1 in 190 puzzles |
| AIC with Groups | Unfair | 340 | 1 in 1,100 puzzles |
| AIC with ALSs | Unfair | 360 | 1 in 590 puzzles |
| Uniqueness | |||
| BUG+1 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 59 puzzles |
| Unique Rectangle Type 1 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 76 puzzles |
| Unique Rectangle Type 2 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 330 puzzles |
| Unique Rectangle Type 3 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 200 puzzles |
| Unique Rectangle Type 4 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 99 puzzles |
| Unique Rectangle Type 5 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 16,000 puzzles |
| Unique Rectangle Type 6 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 300 puzzles |
| Hidden Rectangle | Hard | 100 | 1 in 29 puzzles |
| Avoidable Rectangle Type 1 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 2,000 puzzles |
| Avoidable Rectangle Type 2 | Hard | 100 | 1 in 28,000 puzzles |
| Extended Rectangle | Hard | 110 | 1 in 690 puzzles |
| Miscellaneous | |||
| Sue de Coq | Unfair | 250 | 1 in 320 puzzles |
| Fireworks | Extreme | 400 | 1 in 120,000 puzzles |
| Tridagon | Extreme | 400 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| SK Loop | Extreme | 400 | |
| Aligned Pair Exclusion | Unfair | 320 | 1 in 16,000 puzzles |
| Last Resort | |||
| Exocet | Extreme | 450 | 1 in 160,000 puzzles |
| Double Exocet | Extreme | 480 | |
| Pattern Overlay | Extreme | 500 | 1 in 740 puzzles |
| Forcing Chain | Extreme | 500 | |
| Digit Forcing Chain | Extreme | 500 | 1 in 180 puzzles |
| Nishio Forcing Chain | Extreme | 500 | 1 in 13,000 puzzles |
| Cell Forcing Chain | Extreme | 550 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| Unit Forcing Chain | Extreme | 550 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| Forcing Net | Extreme | 700 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |
| Brute Force | Extreme | 10000 | fewer than 1 in 5,500,000 puzzles |